Guglielmo Vicario debate appears to be over — at least for now. After a series of commanding displays, including a clean sheet against Everton, Gary Neville says he’s revised his opinion on the 29-year-old Italian, who has quietly become one of the Premier League’s most reliable goalkeepers.
Vicario was instrumental in Spurs’ 3-0 win over the Toffees at the weekend, making two key saves and preventing 1.2 expected goals against. His composure and communication have stood out in recent weeks as Tottenham climbed to third in the table.
Neville, who had previously questioned whether Vicario was “good enough to be first choice,” now sees a keeper transformed.
“There were times when I wasn’t 100 per cent on him, but he looks a lot more solid than he has been. They defended really well and the goalkeeper looks a lot better.” — Gary Neville, Sky Sports
From uncertainty to reliability
When Tottenham signed Vicario from Empoli in 2023, many fans — and pundits — viewed him as a gamble. Replacing Hugo Lloris was never going to be straightforward, and early mistakes amplified the scrutiny.
But over time, Vicario’s confidence and consistency have grown. He now boasts six clean sheets this season, including standout performances in both the Premier League and Champions League.
Even David Moyes, whose Everton side were beaten by Spurs, singled out the Italian as a decisive factor in Sunday’s result. Meanwhile, Alan Shearer named him in his Premier League Team of the Week, praising his “two incredible saves” to deny Beto and Iliman Ndiaye.
Guglielmo Vicario – 2025/26 season snapshot
| Stat (2025/26) | Guglielmo Vicario |
|---|---|
| Appearances | 14 |
| Clean Sheets | 6 |
| Saves per Match | 3.8 |
| Goals Prevented (Everton + Monaco) | 3.88 total |
source: Sofascore & Champions League data – 27 October 2025
His shot-stopping numbers now rival the Premier League’s elite. Against Monaco in the Champions League, Vicario made eight saves and was awarded Man of the Match, single-handedly preserving a 1-1 draw.
Our View: Spurs’ quiet backbone
In our view, Vicario’s resurgence symbolises Tottenham’s broader progress under Thomas Frank. The Dane has instilled defensive structure without sacrificing the attacking energy that defines Spurs’ new identity.
Vicario may not have the flamboyance of his predecessor, but his steadiness has been vital. For a team accused of lacking resilience last season, he’s become the calm within the chaos.
Key Insights
- Guglielmo Vicario Tottenham turnaround praised by Gary Neville.
- Six clean sheets already in the 2025/26 campaign.
- Alan Shearer names him in Premier League Team of the Week.
- Man of the Match display in Champions League draw at Monaco.
- Early critics now calling him one of Spurs’ key players.
What’s Next
Tottenham face Chelsea on 1 November 2025, and Vicario is expected to start again as Frank’s side look to consolidate their top-three spot.
With form peaking across two competitions, the Italian’s consistency could be the quiet foundation for a genuine Spurs title challenge.
👉 Has Guglielmo Vicario finally silenced his critics at Tottenham?
0 Comments
First read message
Leave a comment
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *