Chema Andres in action for Brighton in 2026

Stuttgart regret grows over Chema Andrés sale as Brighton midfielder impresses in Premier League

Adem Ozcan Last updated: Nov 16, 2026, 8:24 pm
0

Image: IMAGO / Pro Sports Images

VfB Stuttgart are reportedly facing growing questions over their decision to sell Chema Andrés to Brighton & Hove Albion during the summer transfer window.

The 21-year-old joined the Seagulls for a reported €25 million (£22m) on deadline day and has quickly established himself under Fabian Hürzeler.

According to German newspaper Bild, the decision was not universally supported at Stuttgart, where midfield injuries have since exposed a lack of depth.

Stuttgart face questions over Brighton's Chema Andrés deal

Andrés joined Stuttgart from Real Madrid in July 2025 and made 39 appearances across all competitions during his first season in Germany.

The Spanish midfielder helped Sebastian Hoeneß's side qualify for the Champions League and reach the DFB-Pokal final.

However, he was primarily a rotation option, featuring for just 41% of the available playing time, according to Bild.

Brighton secured his signature in September after meeting Stuttgart's financial conditions.

Although the German club received approximately €25m, Real Madrid were entitled to a substantial share of the fee under an earlier agreement.

Stuttgart sporting director Fabian Wohlgemuth confirmed at the time that the club would have preferred to retain Andrés but respected his desire to move.

Bild now reports that not everyone within Stuttgart understood the decision to sell him so late in the window.

The club have struggled to establish a settled midfield following injuries to Angelo Stiller and Atakan Karazor.

Stuttgart have conceded 15 goals in their opening nine Bundesliga matches, increasing scrutiny of their defensive balance.

Brighton's impressive start increases Stuttgart frustration

Andrés has made an encouraging start at Brighton, where his positioning and passing have helped provide stability in midfield.

The Spaniard has made nine appearances across all competitions and is already playing a more prominent role than he enjoyed at Stuttgart.

Bild reports that he has featured for approximately 63% of Brighton's available league minutes.

His performances have earned him the nickname 'Baby Rodri', reflecting comparisons with the Manchester City midfielder.

Brighton manager Hürzeler has praised Andrés' leadership qualities and credited Hoeneß for helping develop the youngster in Germany.

Real Madrid have also been linked with regret over their decision not to activate a previous buyback option before Brighton completed the transfer.

However, there is no evidence that Brighton are considering selling Andrés or that another club has made an approach.

The midfielder signed a five-year contract when he arrived, leaving Brighton well placed to continue his development.

For Stuttgart, the immediate challenge is finding greater midfield stability while watching a former player flourish in England.

Key Points

  • Bild reports that Stuttgart's decision to sell Chema Andrés to Brighton was not universally supported.
  • The Spaniard joined Brighton for approximately €25m and has become a more regular contributor under Fabian Hürzeler.
  • Stuttgart's midfield injuries have intensified questions over the sale, although Andrés' departure is not the sole explanation for their struggles.

0 Comments

First read message

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Football Place