Italian media have delivered a blunt verdict on Sandro Tonali’s performance for Italy in their 3-0 win over Israel, despite the result effectively sealing qualification for the 2026 World Cup play-offs.
The Newcastle United star, 25, endured a quiet evening in Udine, earning mixed ratings from the national press after struggling to impose himself in midfield. It comes despite a strong club season for Tonali, who has been a driving force in Eddie Howe’s high-flying Magpies side.
Italian outlets critical of Tonali’s showing
According to Calciomercato, Tonali looked off the pace and was “subdued and under-performing” in the first half, earning just a 5.5/10 rating. The outlet wrote:
“When you see him infrequently and rarely hear his name, it’s a sign that the former AC Milan player isn’t having a good night. He tried to get more involved after the break, but the Newcastle man wasn’t able to shine. A yellow card capped a difficult night.” — Calciomercato
Sky Italy offered a slightly kinder 6/10, but noted Tonali’s difficulty adapting from the Premier League’s vertical pace to Italy’s slower, possession-based rhythm:
“He doesn’t lack energy in duels, but his style is more suited to England’s direct play. Surrounded by horizontal passing, he’s not the one to speed things up. Caged.” — Sky Italy
Eurosport Italia echoed the criticism, also giving him 5.5/10 and writing that Tonali “couldn’t make the impact he’d like in midfield” and was again booked late on.
Tonali’s consistency for Newcastle contrasts with Italy struggles
While Italy’s media voiced frustration, Newcastle fans will be less concerned. Tonali has been a near ever-present for the Magpies this season, helping Howe’s side maintain their place in the Premier League’s top seven after lifting the Carabao Cup in March — the club’s first major trophy in 70 years.
The midfielder’s domestic numbers underline his importance.
| Stat (2025/26) | Sandro Tonali |
|---|---|
| Appearances | 9 |
| Goals | 0 |
| Assists | 2 |
| Pass Accuracy | 89 % |
source: sofascore match data – 15 October 2025
Tonali’s crisp distribution and defensive awareness have made him a cornerstone of Newcastle’s midfield, even if that authority didn’t translate to Italy’s game plan in Udine.
Analyst verdict – a one-off, not a warning
In my view, Tonali’s quiet night for Italy feels like a temporary dip rather than a concern. He remains one of the Azzurri’s most complete midfielders and is still rediscovering full rhythm after returning from his betting suspension last year.
FootballPlace analyst John William adds:
“Tonali’s issue isn’t effort — it’s chemistry. He thrives in Newcastle’s high-tempo structure, but Italy’s slower build-up dulls his strengths. Once he’s back in Premier League action, you’ll see the real Tonali again.”
Key insights
- Italian outlets rated Tonali between 5.5 and 6/10 for his display vs Israel.
- Critics said he looked “subdued” and “unable to influence play.”
- Tonali has been a standout for Newcastle this season, helping their top-seven push.
- He’s played in 11 of 12 Premier League matches so far.
- His World Cup chances depend on sustaining form in England.
What’s next for Tonali and Italy?
Italy next face Switzerland in November’s World Cup qualifiers before a likely play-off path in March. Tonali’s starting spot should remain safe, though Solbakken and the Italian press will expect more control from him in midfield.
Back in England, Newcastle resume Premier League duties against Brighton on 18 October, where Tonali will look to prove that his international blip was just that — a blip.
👉 Will Sandro Tonali’s club form be enough to restore his place as Italy’s midfield heartbeat before the 2026 World Cup?
0 Comments
First read message
Leave a comment
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *