Newcastle fans worried after Tino Livramento contract update

Tino Livramento has quickly grown into one of Newcastle United’s most important players since his £32m move from Southampton in 2023 — but serious concerns are now spreading among supporters over his long-term future at St James’ Park. The 23-year-old has become a standout performer under Eddie Howe, yet a new report suggests the club could face a major battle to keep him.

According to the Daily Mail, Livramento has decided to delay contract talks until the end of the season, despite Newcastle being eager to reward him with improved terms. His current deal runs until 2028, but the club want to secure his future well beyond that. With sporting director Ross Wilson making renewed attempts to tie him down, the timing of Livramento’s hesitation has raised alarm bells.

One major factor sits in the background: Manchester City, who attempted to sign Livramento last summer and remain interested as Pep Guardiola continues his search for a long-term right-back.

The news has hit the fanbase hard. Supporters on X (formerly Twitter) immediately began comparing the situation to the departure of Alexander Isak — a saga many still believe the club handled poorly. The online reaction has been a mixture of frustration, fear and resignation.

“We’re gonna have another Isak saga,” wrote one fan.
“Get the £80m and re-invest,” said another.
“If we just keep selling the cream to the big fat cats, we’ll never catch them,” added a third.

Others were even more direct:
“Tino’s gone unfortunately, City will offer him 200k a week.”
“He’s off — waiting to see if we can get Europe next season.”
“There’s another one off then.”

The general mood is clear: the fanbase is bracing for the possibility of losing yet another elite young player in 2026 unless the club drastically improves its competitive position.

As with previous star departures, everything hinges on where Newcastle finish this season. Champions League football remains the single biggest factor that could persuade Livramento to commit long-term. Elite players want elite platforms — and right now, Newcastle are struggling to prove they can offer that consistently.

The demands of juggling Premier League, European and domestic competitions have exposed the squad’s depth issues. Eddie Howe’s side are battling on the fringes of the European places, and unless they crack the top four or secure Europa League qualification, Newcastle risk facing another painful exit.

The club are desperate to avoid a repeat of the Isak situation, which dragged on publicly and caused significant unrest behind the scenes. Losing Livramento in a similar manner would be a major setback to their long-term project.

In our view, Newcastle fans worried Tino Livramento future story is ultimately about ambition. Although some fans argue the club should cash in, the real issue is not the player — it’s Newcastle’s ability to match his trajectory. Livramento is evolving into a top-tier full-back, and clubs like Manchester City will always circle when a project feels uncertain.

From my experience covering situations like this, delayed contract talks are almost always strategic. Players wait to see if the club can match their competitive aspirations. Newcastle cannot rely solely on hope — they need to show progress now, not in two years.

A counterpoint worth mentioning: Livramento has never publicly pushed for an exit. That gives Newcastle time. But the club must strengthen the squad and qualify for Europe, otherwise they risk creating the same environment that allowed Isak’s departure to spiral.

City want a right-back who can invert, carry and press — and Livramento fits their model better than most defenders in Europe. Guardiola’s admiration is a serious variable. If Newcastle do not qualify for the Champions League, City will pounce, offering the wages and project few young players resist.

Newcastle's challenge isn’t convincing Livramento they value him — it’s convincing him they can win with him.

Newcastle’s priority will be securing European qualification and resuming talks with Livramento before the summer. If they cannot show clear progress, the risk of losing one of their brightest young stars in 2026 grows significantly.

👉 Newcastle fans — is Livramento your biggest fear for 2026? Or is this worry premature?