Michael Carrick revival highlights Ruben Amorim’s troubled Man Utd spell

Michael Carrick’s impressive start as Manchester United manager is casting a harsh light on the turbulent spell under his predecessor Ruben Amorim.

United’s recent 3-1 victory over Aston Villa continued Carrick’s remarkable run in charge, meaning the club have now taken 22 points from a possible 27 since he stepped into the role.

The dramatic improvement in performances and results has led many observers to question why things unravelled so badly during Amorim’s 14 months at Old Trafford.

Carrick has quickly restored stability at Manchester United after a period that often felt uncertain under Amorim.

During his tenure, Amorim frequently experimented with a 3-4-2-1 system that many players appeared uncomfortable with. Training sessions were also described as highly prescriptive, while his outspoken press conferences regularly added to the pressure surrounding the squad.

By contrast, Carrick has taken a simpler approach since taking over.

Shorter training sessions, clearer tactical instructions and a calmer public presence have helped bring renewed confidence to the dressing room.

The change has translated onto the pitch, where United look far more balanced both defensively and in attack.

One of Carrick’s most significant tactical decisions has been restoring a familiar 4-2-3-1 formation.

The system appears to better suit the profile of players in the squad and has allowed several individuals to rediscover their best form.

Full-backs Diogo Dalot and Luke Shaw are once again operating in natural roles, while the centre-back partnership looks more comfortable in a traditional back four.

Casemiro has also benefited from greater midfield support, helping stabilise United’s defensive structure.

Perhaps the most striking example of the tactical shift involves captain Bruno Fernandes.

Under Amorim, the Portuguese playmaker was often deployed deeper in midfield, limiting his influence in attacking areas.

Carrick immediately returned Fernandes to a more advanced role behind the striker, and the results have been impressive.

In nine matches under Carrick, Fernandes has registered two goals and eight assists, making him one of the most productive players in the Premier League during that period.

Carrick’s approach has also revitalised other players who struggled during the previous regime.

Young midfielder Kobbie Mainoo, who did not start a single Premier League match under Amorim this season, has become a key figure in the current setup.

Meanwhile, striker Benjamin Sesko has flourished in a more attacking system after previously struggling for service in Amorim’s formation.

The increased attacking freedom has allowed United to commit more players forward and create significantly more chances.

With United now performing at a high level again, Amorim’s time in charge is likely to come under increasing scrutiny.

The Portuguese coach spent 63 games in charge, but his tenure ultimately ended with the club struggling for identity and consistency.

Carrick’s early success has reignited the debate about whether the tactical direction under Amorim was simply incompatible with the players available at Old Trafford.

Manchester United will aim to continue their strong form as they chase Champions League qualification in the closing stages of the Premier League season.

If Carrick’s impressive run continues, the club may face an important decision about his long-term future in the dugout.