Jamie Carragher believes Eddie Howe has reached the ceiling of what is possible at Newcastle United under the current ownership structure. Speaking after the Magpies’ 3–1 defeat at Brentford, the Sky Sports pundit claimed that the Public Investment Fund (PIF) has “let Howe down” and that the club’s off-field instability has stalled progress.
Newcastle’s poor start to the 2025/26 Premier League season has left them hovering just two points above the relegation zone — a far cry from their Champions League qualification and Carabao Cup success under Howe. Carragher suggested that while Howe remains one of Newcastle’s greatest modern managers, he may have taken the project as far as possible under present conditions.
Could Eddie Howe really walk away from Newcastle for England next summer?
Carragher: Newcastle have hit their limit under PIF and Howe
Carragher, speaking on Sky Sports after Sunday’s loss, reflected on the progress made since PIF’s takeover in 2021 but argued that the club has now plateaued.
“Now that we’re four years in, I don’t think Eddie Howe can do any more than what he’s done at Newcastle. He’s won a trophy. He’s got Champions League football. I don’t see Newcastle winning a Premier League, so I’m not sure there’s much more he can do.” — Jamie Carragher, Sky Sports
The former Liverpool defender said structural issues have hampered Howe’s ability to build sustainably, citing confusion over sporting directors and transfer mismanagement. “It almost feels like he’s there on his own,” Carragher said, adding that “the big Saudi investment hasn’t really kicked on.”
Carragher also criticised Newcastle’s handling of the summer transfer window, pointing to late deals and ongoing PSR (Profit and Sustainability Rules) constraints as evidence that Howe has been operating without the full backing of the hierarchy.
Pundit claims Howe ‘deserves better’ from ownership
The 47-year-old pundit didn’t hold back when assessing the internal dynamics at St James’ Park, insisting Howe has not been adequately supported by PIF’s leadership group.
“He’s had problems with sporting directors and people at the top of the club,” Carragher added. “The [Alexander] Isak situation, getting players in late, the [Yoane] Wissa situation — it’s been a mess. I think when you’re talking about one of the greatest managers they’ve ever had, he deserves better.”
Despite the criticism, Carragher acknowledged that Howe still retains the full respect of Newcastle supporters and players alike. However, he believes both the manager and the club are now at a crossroads.
Carragher tips Howe for future England role
In perhaps his boldest suggestion, Carragher advised Howe to keep a close eye on the England managerial situation after next summer’s World Cup. Current boss Thomas Tuchel’s contract runs until 2026, but his future beyond the tournament remains uncertain.
“If I’m thinking how Eddie Howe’s thinking, if that England job came up in the summer after the World Cup, I’d be there in a shot. Because I think he’s been let down, and I don’t think he can take Newcastle any further than what he’s done so far.” — Jamie Carragher
Carragher believes Howe’s tactical flexibility, man-management skills, and record of developing English talent make him a prime candidate for the FA if Tuchel departs. The FA are known admirers of Howe’s work, having previously considered him when Gareth Southgate stepped down in 2024.
FA stance on Eddie Howe remains positive
Reports in 2024 suggested the Football Association (FA) viewed Howe as a leading domestic candidate for the England job before ultimately appointing Tuchel. Sources close to the FA still describe Howe as a “respected and proven” English coach capable of managing at international level.
However, Newcastle’s ownership remains publicly supportive of their manager. PIF executives see Howe as central to their long-term project, even amid this turbulent spell. That said, the growing frustration around recruitment delays and internal reshuffles could yet test Howe’s patience.
Analyst Verdict: Howe caught between loyalty and opportunity
FootballPlace believe Carragher’s comments reflect a broader truth about Newcastle’s stalled evolution. “Eddie Howe has delivered historic success under restrictions that many top managers wouldn’t tolerate,” he said. “But if Newcastle’s ownership can’t provide clarity and consistent backing, his options will naturally widen.”
“The England job could tempt him — not because he’s given up, but because he’s done everything possible in this environment. If PIF want to keep him, they’ll need to show a stronger footballing structure behind the scenes.”
Key Insights
- Carragher says Newcastle have “hit their ceiling” under Eddie Howe and PIF.
- Pundit believes Howe has been “let down” by instability and recruitment issues.
- Carragher urges Howe to consider the England job post-World Cup 2026.
- FA sources remain admirers of Howe’s tactical and developmental record.
- Howe still retains full support of PIF despite Newcastle’s poor start.
What’s Next for Eddie Howe and Newcastle?
Newcastle’s next fixture after the international break sees them host Manchester City at St James’ Park — a must-win for Howe as pressure mounts. A string of positive results could ease the narrative, but off-field questions about PIF’s long-term sporting strategy will persist.
If Newcastle fail to improve before Christmas, speculation over Howe’s future — and potential links to the England job — will only intensify. For now, Howe’s focus remains on stabilising the team and reigniting their form before 2026.
👉 Should Eddie Howe stay loyal to Newcastle or move on to the England job if it becomes available?
1 Comment (last comment by JamesLove)
First read message
By JamesLove 10 Nov 2025 08:53
Let down? He has spend a lot of money. Many players didn’t want to join Newcastle and that’s not only the PIF it’s on Howe as well. He couldn’t convince the players to join them. With all respect he’s not an elite manager who convince players to join them
Leave a comment
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *