Liverpool’s perfect start to the season has given them an early edge in the Premier League title race, according to Jamie Carragher and Roy Keane. The pundits analysed Arsenal’s late 1-1 draw with Manchester City at the Emirates, which left Arne Slot’s side five points clear at the summit after just five games.
Gabriel Martinelli’s stoppage-time equaliser rescued a point for the Gunners after Erling Haaland had put City in front during the first half. But despite Arsenal’s spirited fightback, both Carragher and Keane raised doubts about their attacking creativity, suggesting that Liverpool remain in pole position given their ability to grind out wins even when not at their best.
Slot’s men recorded a 2-1 win over Everton at the weekend to maintain their flawless record. They now sit ahead of Tottenham, Bournemouth and Arsenal in the early table. While Liverpool’s performances have not always been at full throttle, their knack for securing results has been enough to establish them as early frontrunners. For Carragher and Keane, that ruthless edge separates them from an Arsenal side still struggling to convince.
Carragher questions Arsenal’s attacking spark
The former Liverpool defender admitted he was impressed with Arsenal’s control of the game but underlined concerns about their lack of cutting edge.
“I can’t get away from the fact that Arsenal don’t look like they’re going to score a goal in open play. I felt that at Manchester United, Anfield and today. Fair play, they got the goal today but it has to be a big worry for Arsenal. They didn’t really look like scoring, that was a problem last season and it still looks like in these five games they’ve still got it.” — Jamie Carragher
Carragher also pointed to Declan Rice’s post-match optimism about Arsenal’s dominance, but insisted that control without penetration is not enough to win a title.
Keane: Arsenal still “short” compared to Liverpool
Roy Keane echoed Carragher’s concerns, adding that Arsenal do not yet measure up to Liverpool or the great Manchester City sides of recent years.
“Possession doesn’t win you football matches. Were they going to create something? We talk about strength in depth, subs coming off the bench and having a big involvement in the goal, but it’s the same issues. When you see what Liverpool are doing, Man City have done, they’re still short. They’re a good team but the standards of the other teams, they still look short in that area.” — Roy Keane
Keane also noted City’s transitional state under Pep Guardiola, with their lack of intensity and failure to push for a second goal allowing Arsenal back into the match.
Liverpool’s perfect start shifts title momentum
Liverpool’s early form has been defined by resilience rather than free-flowing brilliance. Wins over Everton, Tottenham and Chelsea have come with moments of struggle, yet Slot’s side continue to deliver maximum points. For Keane and Carragher, that efficiency is a hallmark of champions.
| Stat (2025/26) | Liverpool |
|---|---|
| Games played | 5 |
| Wins | 5 |
| Draws | 0 |
| Losses | 0 |
| Points | 15 |
source: sofascore match data – 21 September 2025
The numbers underline why Liverpool are already considered favourites. Even without their best form, they remain unbeaten and ruthless in crucial moments.
Analyst verdict
FootballPlace analyst John William believes Liverpool’s edge is psychological as much as tactical. “Carragher and Keane are right — Liverpool haven’t played at full speed yet, but they keep finding a way to win. That consistency, while rivals stumble, is a major advantage. Arsenal’s lack of creativity is concerning when you consider the demands of a 38-game season.”
He added that City’s dip in dominance has opened the door for both Liverpool and Arsenal, but only one looks ready to walk through it. “City look vulnerable, Arsenal lack bite, but Liverpool already have the aura of champions. That is why Carragher and Keane are leaning their way.”
Key insights
- Liverpool five points clear at the top after five straight wins.
- Arsenal rescued a 1-1 draw with Man City but looked blunt in attack.
- Jamie Carragher says Arsenal don’t look like scoring from open play.
- Roy Keane insists Arsenal are still “short” compared to Liverpool and City.
- Liverpool’s ability to win without peak performance gives them title advantage.
What’s next in the title race?
Liverpool now prepare for clashes with Southampton in the League Cup and Crystal Palace away. If Slot’s men maintain their perfect run, pressure will intensify on Arsenal to prove they can compete over the long haul.
For Arsenal, the upcoming fixtures are an opportunity to silence doubters. Creativity in open play must improve, otherwise their title bid could unravel before winter. For now, Carragher and Keane see Liverpool holding all the cards.
👉 Do you agree with Carragher and Keane — is Liverpool already the team to beat in this season’s Premier League title race?
0 Comments
First read message
Leave a comment
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *